Entering the USA with a criminal record: ESTA or visa?
A criminal record does not automatically rule out a trip to the USA. Which ESTA questions apply, how the US side may view penalty orders, fines and expungement, and when you need a visa.

Contents
- Which ESTA questions concern a criminal record?
- What counts as a criminal record under US law?
- Are there exceptions for minor or early offenses?
- What is a "conviction", and what is not?
- Penalty order, daily-rate fines, expungement: how does the US side see German terms?
- Why a "clean" certificate of conduct is not enough
- Which offenses are typical, and what applies to each?
- Traffic offenses
- Drunk driving
- Drugs and cannabis
- Theft, fraud and tax offenses
- Assault
- Juvenile offenses and multiple convictions
- How should you proceed with a criminal record? Step by step
- What happens if you give false information?
- Will the US authorities learn about my conviction?
- When is advice or a legal review useful?
A criminal record does not automatically bar you from entering the USA. What matters is the type of offense, the sentence and the exact wording of the ESTA questions: if you have to answer one of them truthfully with "yes", you will generally need a B-1/B-2 visitor visa instead of ESTA. Whether a ground of inadmissibility applies is decided case by case by the US authorities under US law, not by what your German certificate of conduct shows. False statements usually weigh more heavily than the conviction itself, because they can lead to a permanent bar.
This guide explains which ESTA questions concern criminal records, how the US side may classify German terms such as Strafbefehl (penalty order), daily-rate fines or expungement, and how to proceed step by step (as of November 2026). It is non-binding guidance, not legal advice. The basics of choosing between the two routes are covered in ESTA or visa?, and our Visa Check gives you an initial assessment of your trip.
Which ESTA questions concern a criminal record?
The ESTA application contains nine eligibility questions that you answer with yes or no. Questions 2 and 3 are the key ones for criminal records; questions 1 and 5 touch on the topic. The wording below is taken from the official ESTA website esta.cbp.dhs.gov (as of November 2026); the German version is the official translation on the same site. We have not checked the wording in the ESTA app.
| No. | Wording (English) | Official German version |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | "Have you ever been arrested or convicted for a crime that resulted in serious damage to property, or serious harm to another person or government authority?" | „Wurden Sie jemals verhaftet oder eines Verbrechens überführt, das zu ernsthaften Sachschäden oder gravierenden Schäden für andere Personen oder Regierungsbehörden geführt hat?“ |
| 3 | "Have you ever violated any law related to possessing, using, or distributing illegal drugs?" | „Haben Sie jemals Gesetzesübertretungen im Zusammenhang mit dem Besitz oder Gebrauch bzw. der Verteilung von illegalen Drogen begangen?“ |
| 1 (excerpt) | "… or are you a drug abuser or addict …" | „… missbrauchen Sie Drogen oder sind Sie drogensüchtig …“ |
| 5 | "Have you ever committed fraud or misrepresented yourself or others to obtain, or assist others to obtain, a visa or entry into the United States?" | „Haben Sie jemals betrügerische Handlungen begangen oder haben Sie sich Anderen gegenüber fälschlich dargestellt, um ein Visum bzw. den Zutritt zu den Vereinigten Staaten zu erlangen, oder haben Sie anderen Personen dazu verholfen?“ |
Three points matter when reading them:
- Question 2 targets "moral turpitude". According to the help text of US Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the question refers to "crimes involving moral turpitude", meaning conduct that is "inherently base, vile, or depraved". Focusing only on the words "damage to property" or "harm to another person" therefore falls short. The question also asks whether you were "arrested or convicted", so an arrest alone is covered.
- Question 3 does not require a conviction. It asks whether you have ever violated a drug law ("violated any law"), not whether there were proceedings.
- The old combined question is gone. Many older guides quote a question about two or more convictions with an aggregate sentence of at least five years. It no longer appears in this form on the current website, although the ground of inadmissibility itself still exists in the statute.
CBP's FAQ sets the direction: if you believe that any ground of inadmissibility under § 212(a) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) applies to you, you should apply for a nonimmigrant visa before traveling. If any of your answers changes, a new ESTA application is required anyway (8 CFR 217.5).
What counts as a criminal record under US law?
The ESTA questions summarize what the statute says. The relevant provision is INA § 212(a)(2). Under it, a person is generally inadmissible who
- has been convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT) or admits committing the essential elements of such a crime,
- has violated a law relating to a controlled substance, expressly including foreign law,
- has been convicted of two or more offenses with aggregate sentences to confinement of five years or more, whatever the offenses were,
- is believed by the consular officer to have been involved in drug trafficking; here, "reason to believe" is enough, even without a conviction.
According to the US State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual (9 FAM 302.3), whether an offense is a CIMT is determined under US federal law and by the statutory definition of the offense, not by the specific facts of the case. This also applies to foreign convictions. Typical examples are offenses involving deceit or intent to gain, such as theft and fraud. Simple drunk driving, by contrast, is expressly listed in the FAM as an offense without moral turpitude.
Are there exceptions for minor or early offenses?
The statute contains two exceptions. They apply only to a single CIMT and never to drug offenses:
- Youthful offender: the offense was committed before the age of 18, and both the offense and any release from confinement occurred more than five years before the application.
- Petty offense: the maximum penalty possible for the offense does not exceed one year of imprisonment, and the sentence imposed was no more than six months, even if it was suspended.
In our assessment, the petty offense exception rarely helps with German offenses. It depends on the statutory maximum penalty, which is five years for theft (§ 242 of the German Criminal Code, StGB) and fraud (§ 263 StGB), even if only a small fine was imposed in the specific case. The consular officer's assessment is what counts.
What is a "conviction", and what is not?
Under INA § 101(a)(48), a conviction is a formal judgment of guilt entered by a court, or a finding or plea of guilty followed by some form of punishment or restraint ordered by a judge. For prison sentences, the term imposed counts even if it was suspended. According to the FAM, an investigation, an arrest or a charge alone is not a conviction, but it can delay the visa process until the proceedings are over.
Important if your entry has already been deleted: a foreign pardon, amnesty or expungement does not remove the ground of inadmissibility (22 CFR 40.21(a)(5); for drug offenses likewise under 9 FAM 302.4). According to the FAM, the consular officer decides whether a conviction exists independently of any database record.
Expunged does not mean forgotten: Under § 53 of the German Federal Central Criminal Register Act (BZRG), you may under certain conditions describe yourself as having no criminal record. That applies within the German legal system. For US authorities, in our assessment, the conviction generally still exists, even if it no longer appears on any certificate of conduct.
Penalty order, daily-rate fines, expungement: how does the US side see German terms?
There is no official US translation table for German legal terms. The right-hand column is therefore our assessment based on US statute, the FAM and German federal law; the consular officer makes the binding decision in each case.
| German term | Meaning in Germany | Possible classification from a US perspective |
|---|---|---|
| Strafbefehl (penalty order) | penalty imposed without a trial at the prosecutor's request; without an objection within two weeks it has the effect of a final judgment (§§ 407, 410 StPO) | usually treated in practice like a conviction; not a loophole |
| Geldstrafe in Tagessätzen (daily-rate fine) | 5 to 360 daily rates of 1 to 30,000 euros each (§ 40 StGB) | a fine alone is still a punishment under the US definition |
| Freiheitsstrafe auf Bewährung (suspended prison sentence) | suspension possible for sentences up to one year, exceptionally up to two years (§ 56 StGB) | counts with the term imposed, as if it had been served (INA § 101(a)(48)(B)) |
| Einstellung gegen Auflage (dismissal with conditions, § 153a StPO) | proceedings dropped against a payment or other conditions; no judgment, no entry in the Federal Central Criminal Register | not officially clarified; disclose it in the visa process and bring documents |
| Verwarnung mit Strafvorbehalt (warning with deferred sentence, § 59 StGB) | finding of guilt, the penalty is reserved; entered in the register, not shown on the certificate of conduct | not officially clarified; disclose it |
| Bundeszentralregister (BZR, Federal Central Criminal Register) | register of final criminal convictions kept by the Federal Office of Justice (§§ 3, 4 BZRG) | the consular officer decides independently of the register |
| Führungszeugnis (certificate of conduct) | extract from the register, but not complete (§§ 32, 34 BZRG) | corresponds to a "police certificate"; a clean certificate does not prove there is no conviction |
| Tilgung (expungement), "unbestraft" | entry generally deleted after 5 to 20 years depending on the sentence and may no longer be held against the person (§§ 46, 51, 53 BZRG) | foreign expungement does not remove US grounds of inadmissibility (22 CFR 40.21) |
| Jugendstrafe, Erziehungsmaßregeln (youth sentence, educational measures) | youth sentences are in the BZR, educational and disciplinary measures in the separate educational register (§ 60 BZRG) | special rules for offenses under 18 (see case groups) |
Why a "clean" certificate of conduct is not enough
The certificate of conduct does not show everything. A first conviction to no more than 90 daily rates or three months in prison is not included if nothing else is registered (§ 32(2) no. 5 BZRG; not for certain sexual offenses). Other entries disappear from the certificate after three, five or ten years (§ 34 BZRG) but remain in the register until they are expunged. The ESTA and visa questions, by contrast, refer to the offense, the arrest or the conviction, not to the state of the register.
You can see all entries in the information for data subjects under § 42 BZRG. You can inspect it at the Federal Office of Justice, a local court or a German mission abroad; no copy is handed out. It is valuable for your own clarification, but it cannot serve as a document for the consulate.
Which offenses are typical, and what applies to each?
The following case groups show tendencies, not outcomes. The US authorities assess every case individually, and even small differences in the statutory definition can change the classification.
Traffic offenses
Administrative fines, for example for speeding, concern regulatory offenses (Ordnungswidrigkeiten). Under German law these are not crimes and not convictions; in our assessment they are generally irrelevant to the ESTA questions. For traffic crimes, the statutory definition matters: negligent offenses rarely meet the CIMT definition.
Drunk driving
According to the FAM, simple drunk driving (§ 316 StGB, maximum penalty one year) is not a CIMT, although aggravated forms can be. According to CBP, ESTA question 2 targets "moral turpitude", and under US consular practice simple drunk driving generally does not fall into that category. If in doubt, applying for a visa is the safe route. In the visa process, the consular officer refers you to a panel physician designated by the embassy if there has been one alcohol-related arrest or conviction within the last five years or two within the last ten years (9 FAM 302.2). This lengthens the process. A refusal on medical grounds only follows if the physician finds harmful behavior with a risk of recurrence.
Drugs and cannabis
This is where US law is strictest. Question 3 does not require a conviction, the petty offense exception does not apply, and according to the FAM an expungement does not help either. Cannabis is a controlled substance under US federal law; whether it is legal under foreign law is irrelevant according to the FAM. Germany's partial legalization of 1 April 2024 and the expungement of old cannabis entries on application under §§ 40 to 42 of the Consumer Cannabis Act (KCanG) therefore do not change the US assessment. With drug offenses, getting advice before any application is especially important.
Theft, fraud and tax offenses
Theft and fraud are considered typical CIMT offenses. Because their maximum penalty in Germany is five years, in our assessment the petty offense exception does not apply even to a small fine, for example after shoplifting. For tax offenses, it depends on whether deceit or intent is part of the statutory definition; there is no blanket answer.
Assault
Under US case law, simple bodily injury is generally not classified as a CIMT. This can be different with aggravating features such as a dangerous weapon or serious injuries. Because question 2 expressly mentions "serious harm to another person", you should review violent offenses with particular care.
Juvenile offenses and multiple convictions
Offenses committed before the age of 15 do not lead to CIMT inadmissibility; between 15 and 18 only if the person was tried and convicted as an adult for a violent felony (22 CFR 40.21(a)(2)). If an additional CIMT is involved, inadmissibility can still apply. Multiple convictions with aggregate sentences to confinement of five years or more are generally a bar, even if no single offense is a CIMT.
How should you proceed with a criminal record? Step by step
- Find out what is registered. Inspect the information for data subjects and request a certificate of conduct from the Federal Office of Justice (13 euros; since 1 October 2026 also available digitally for private individuals as a PDF in the BundID mailbox; from abroad directly from the Federal Office).
- Collect the court documents. These include the judgment or penalty order, the indictment if applicable, proof that fines were paid or probation ended, the text of the criminal provision applied with its range of penalties, and English translations.
- Check the ESTA questions honestly. The wording is what counts, not the state of the register. If you have to answer a question with "yes" or have serious doubts, do not apply for ESTA.
- Apply for a B-1/B-2 visa. The application starts with the online form DS-160, which in substance asks about every arrest or conviction, even if pardoned or covered by an amnesty. How the form works is explained in Completing the DS-160, and the visa category itself in B-1/B-2 basics. The application fee is 185 US dollars and is not refunded if the visa is refused. The Visa Integrity Fee of at least 250 US dollars has been law since July 2025; whether and from when the US missions in Germany will collect it has not been officially announced.
- Prepare for the interview. In Germany, visas are issued in Berlin, Frankfurt and Munich. An interview waiver requires, among other things, that no potential ineligibility is apparent, so with a criminal record you should expect an interview. In mid-October 2026, wait times were under two weeks in Berlin and Munich and up to two and a half months in Frankfurt (US State Department, as of 21 October 2026). Tips on the procedure are in The visa interview at the embassy.
- Expect follow-up checks. If the consular officer has reason to believe a criminal record exists, they can require a police certificate (22 CFR 41.105(a)(4)). They may request further documents or refer you to a panel physician; the decision then takes longer.
- If a ground of inadmissibility applies: a waiver. Under INA § 212(d)(3)(A), a visitor visa can be issued despite a ground of inadmissibility. The consular officer or the State Department must recommend the waiver, and CBP's Admissibility Review Office decides. According to the FAM, processing "is usually 365 days", so expect it to take up to a year. A waiver is valid for no more than 60 months for multiple entries and is at the authorities' discretion.
There is no such waiver under ESTA: anyone who is inadmissible cannot travel visa-free (8 CFR 217.4). And even with a visa, the border officer decides on arrival. What is checked there is explained in Entry, customs and CBP.
What happens if you give false information?
Under INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(i), anyone who seeks a visa or admission by fraud or by willfully misrepresenting a material fact is inadmissible. The statute sets no time limit; the US State Department describes it as a permanent ineligibility. According to the FAM (9 FAM 302.9), this also applies to the ESTA application. CBP warns that reapplying with false information after a denial makes a traveler permanently ineligible for the Visa Waiver Program. An honest mistake is not a misrepresentation; deliberate concealment is.
Important: Anyone who deliberately conceals a criminal record on ESTA or in the DS-160 risks a lifetime bar for misrepresentation. That is usually more serious than the conviction itself. If you answered a question incorrectly in the past, get advice before you apply again or travel.
Note that an ESTA denial is not a visa refusal (8 CFR 217.5(f)(2)). According to CBP, however, a new ESTA application with unchanged circumstances will be denied again; the way forward is then a visa. More in ESTA denied: what to do.
Will the US authorities learn about my conviction?
How much the US side knows in a given case cannot be judged from the outside. Under § 57 BZRG, foreign authorities can obtain information from the German register under certain conditions, and a German-US agreement from 2008 governs the comparison of fingerprints and DNA profiles to combat serious crime. The US is also expanding data exchange with Visa Waiver countries: Executive Order 14385 of 6 February 2026 allows the reciprocal exchange of criminal history records, and agreements on comparing further data including biometrics are due by 31 December 2026 (see new entry rules). Your answers should not depend on any of this anyway.
When is advice or a legal review useful?
With criminal records there are hardly any standard answers. Advice before applying makes sense as soon as you are unsure how to answer an ESTA question. A review by a lawyer specializing in US immigration law is particularly advisable for drug offenses, multiple convictions, violent offenses, past misrepresentations or if a waiver may become necessary.
We support you in preparing your visitor visa application (B-2 visa) and help clarify your situation in an individual consultation. This does not replace legal advice in your specific case. The decision on visa and entry rests solely with the US authorities.
Frequently asked questions
Can I travel to the USA on ESTA with a criminal record?+
It depends on the offense and on the wording of the ESTA questions. If you do not have to answer any eligibility question with "yes", you can apply for ESTA; if you must answer one with "yes", for example about arrests for crimes involving moral turpitude or about drug violations, you will generally need a B-1/B-2 visa. US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) expressly recommends applying for a visa if a ground of inadmissibility may apply. The US authorities decide each case individually.
Do I have to declare an expunged conviction on ESTA?+
The ESTA questions ask whether you have ever been arrested or convicted, not what the German Federal Central Criminal Register currently shows. Under US law (22 CFR 40.21), a foreign expungement does not remove a ground of inadmissibility. Whether an expunged offense falls under an ESTA question depends on the offense; if in doubt, applying for a visa is the safe route. Get advice before you apply.
Does a German penalty order or fine count as a conviction in the USA?+
A final German penalty order (Strafbefehl) has the same effect as a final judgment in Germany (§ 410(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Under the US definition of a conviction, it is usually treated as a conviction in practice; a fine alone is still a punishment. There is no official US statement specifically on penalty orders, and the consular officer makes the binding decision in each case.
What happens if I conceal a criminal record on ESTA?+
Deliberately false answers on ESTA or in a visa application are a separate ground of inadmissibility under INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(i), and it is permanent. According to CBP, reapplying with false information makes a traveler permanently ineligible for the Visa Waiver Program. This is usually more serious than the conviction itself. An honest mistake is not a misrepresentation, but it should be clarified with advice before your next trip.
Can I enter the USA after a drunk-driving conviction?+
According to the US State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual, simple drunk driving is not a crime involving moral turpitude and is not, on its own, a criminal ground of inadmissibility. According to CBP, ESTA question 2 targets such crimes; if in doubt, applying for a visa is the safe route. In the visa process, the consular officer refers applicants with an alcohol-related arrest or conviction within the last five years to a panel physician, which lengthens the process.
Does an old cannabis conviction still matter for the USA?+
Yes, it can. Cannabis is a controlled substance under US federal law, and according to the US State Department it is irrelevant whether it is legal under foreign law. Expunging old cannabis entries under Germany's Consumer Cannabis Act does not change the US assessment either, and there is no petty offense exception for drug offenses. Get advice before applying for ESTA or a visa.
How long does a waiver for a US visa take?+
A waiver under INA § 212(d)(3)(A) must be recommended by the consular officer or the State Department and is decided by CBP's Admissibility Review Office. According to the Foreign Affairs Manual, processing usually takes 365 days and sometimes longer. An approved waiver is valid for no more than 60 months for multiple entries; no waiver is possible through ESTA.
Sources
- 22 CFR 41.105 – Supporting documents and police certificates · eCFR (Office of the Federal Register)
- Führungszeugnis beantragen · Bundesamt für Justiz
- ESTA – Eignungsfragen, Hilfetexte und FAQ (offizielle Website) · U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
- 9 FAM 305.4 – Waivers of Ineligibility for Nonimmigrants (INA 212(d)(3)(A)) · U.S. Department of State (Foreign Affairs Manual)
- 8 U.S.C. § 1182 – Inadmissible aliens (INA § 212) · Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives
- Bundeszentralregistergesetz (BZRG) · Bundesministerium der Justiz (gesetze-im-internet.de)
- 22 CFR 40.21 – Crimes involving moral turpitude and controlled substance violators · eCFR (Office of the Federal Register)
- 9 FAM 302.9 – Immigration Violators incl. Misrepresentation (INA 212(a)(6)) · U.S. Department of State (Foreign Affairs Manual)
- 9 FAM 302.3 – Ineligibility Based on Criminal Activity (INA 212(a)(2)) · U.S. Department of State (Foreign Affairs Manual)
Not sure what you need?
Find out in two minutes whether ESTA or a visa is right for you. We guide you personally through your visa application.
US-Visa-Service Redaktion
US entry & visa editorial team
Carefully researched and regularly reviewed. Non-binding guidance — the final decision on entry and visas rests solely with the US authorities.
Keep reading

U.S. Airport Entry: The Arrival Process, CBP & Customs
How entering the United States at the airport actually works – from CBP inspection with biometric facial comparison to the electronic I‑94 record and customs declaration. With tips, typical officer questions and 2026 customs rules.
Read
Connecting Flights in the USA: Transit, Domestic Flights and TSA Rules
Connecting in the USA always means entering the country: what you need for transit, how the process works at the first airport, how much connection time is realistic and which TSA rules apply on domestic flights.
Read
Entering the USA with Children: Passport, ESTA and Consent Letter
Every child needs their own electronic passport and their own ESTA or visa for the USA. This guide shows which additional documents each family situation calls for and what applies to baby food, car seats and vaccinations.
Read